The New Testament model is for each local church to be led by a team of pastoral elders with no sole senior or lead pastor. (I’ve written quite a bit about this; if you’re interested, you could start reading here.) From time to time, people ask me for examples of such elder-led churches. The following list is a tiny sample of churches with a biblical eldership. For the most part, these are simply churches I’ve happened to run across online. To my knowledge, all these churches are evangelical Christian churches who enjoy shared pastoral leadership with no sole designated senior leader (other than Christ himself). I can’t otherwise endorse every church here. They run the gamut theologically. If you know of a church that could be added to this list (solidly evangelical and led by elders with no sole senior/lead pastor), add a comment and let me know.
Alaska
Anchorage
Faith Christian Community
Arizona
Tempe
New Covenant Bible Fellowship
Arkansas
Hot Springs
Lake Valley Community Church
Little Rock
Midtown Baptist Church
California
Alameda
Alameda Chapel
Boonville
Valley Bible Fellowship
Cupertino
Hillview Bible Chapel
Peninsula Bible Church Cupertino
El Segundo
Oceanside Christian Fellowship
Fremont
Calvary Bible Chapel
Fullerton / La Mirada
Grace Evangelical Free Church
Gerber
Gerber Bible Fellowship
Grass Valley
Veritas Church
Hayward
Community Bible Chapel
Lafayette
Sun Valley Bible Chapel
Lancaster
Valley Bible Church
Los Angeles
Crossview Church
Milpitas
Milpitas Bible Fellowship
New Covenant Christian Fellowship
Pacifica
Vintage Grace Communities
Palo Alto
Peninsula Bible Church
Pleasanton
Valley Bible Church
Rancho Palos Verdes
South Bay Evangelical Christian Church
Rohnert Park
Rohnert Park Bible Church
Sacramento
The Orchard
San Diego
Mission Valley Community Chapel
The Resolved Church
San Jose
Grace Bible Chapel
Peninsula Bible Church Willow Glen
San Leandro
Fairhaven Bible Chapel
Santa Rosa
Soma Church Community
South Lake Tahoe
Sierra Community Church
Colorado
Brighton
Redeemer Bible Church
Littleton
Littleton Bible Chapel
Loveland
River of Life Christian Fellowship
Florida
Fort Myers
Summit Church
Orlando
H2O Church
Georgia
Augusta
New Heart Bible Fellowship
Tucker
Atlanta Reformation Fellowship
Hawaii
Maui
Kihei
Kihei Baptist Chapel
Idaho
Boise
Cole Community Church
Illinois
Chicago
Assyrian Christian Church
Long Grove
Life on the Vine
Kentucky
Louisville
Clifton Baptist Church
Somerset
The Chapel at Somerset
Massachusetts
Princeton
Heritage Bible Chapel
Southbridge
Sovereign Grace Chapel
Michigan
Lansing
Riverview Church
Redford
Dunning Park Bible Chapel
Minnesota
Bloomington
Sovereign Grace Church
St Paul
The Heights Church
Mississippi
Coldwater
Grace Bible Church
New Albany
Christ Church
Missouri
Branson
Harvest Evangelical Free Church
Carthage
Cornerstone Baptist Church
Fenton
Fenton Crossing Bible Chapel
Rogersville
The Summit Church
St Louis
The Gate Church
Montana
Hamilton
Bitterroot Harvest Community Church
Nebraska
Lincoln
First Street Bible Church
Norfolk
Victory Road Evangelical Free Church
New Jersey
Denville
Christ the King Church
New Mexico
Albuquerque
Heritage Christian Fellowship
New York
Brockport
Clarkson Community Church
Lake Katrine
Fountain of Life Christian Church
Rochester
Clay Jars Christian Fellowship
Crossroads Bible Fellowship
North Carolina
Wake Forest
Messiah Baptist Church
Ohio
Beavercreek
Grace Covenant Church
Patterson Park Church
Canal Winchester
NewLife Community Church
Canton
Faith Bible Church
Fresno
Fresno Bible Church
Oklahoma
Tulsa
Tulsa Christian Fellowship
Oregon
Clackamas
Spring Mountain Bible Church
Eugene
Willamette Bible Chapel
Gresham
Clear Creek Church
Clinton Street Bible Chapel
Hood River
Pillar Bible Fellowship
Oregon City
Oregon City Bible Chapel
Portland
Evergreen
Tangent
Grace Bible Fellowship
South Carolina
Greenville
LifePoint Church
Greenville / Piedmont / Simpsonville / Spartanburg / Anderson
Grace Church
Moore
Grace Bible Church
Tennessee
Powell
First Baptist Church
Texas
Canyon Lake
Church in the Valley
College Station
New Life Baptist Church
Garland
Household of Faith
Richardson
Community Bible Chapel
Spring
Covenant Church of Spring
Grace Family Baptist Church
Virginia
Dulles
Reston Bible Church
North Chesterfield
Bethany Place Baptist Church
Radford
Christ Church–Radford
Washington
Kent
Faith Church
Olympia
Reality Church
Veradale
Valley Bible Church
Walla Walla
Mission Church
West Virginia
Huntington
Redemption Church
Wisconsin
Chippewa Falls
Chippewa Valley Bible Church
Guam
Hagatna
Grace Fellowship
Puerto Rico
Rincón
Rincón Beach Church
Canada
British Columbia
Vancouver
Trinity Central
Ontario
Mississauga
New Life Bible Chapel
the Netherlands
Amstelveen
Crossroads International Church
Online
http://www.churchofthecrossaz.com/
Thanks, Brent. Looks great. I’ve added you guys to the list.
I have attended several plural elder led churches over the years in California. Most of them are “Plymouth Brethren” affiliated, at least initially. Among them are Rohnert Park Bible Church in Rohnert Park, Fairhaven Bible Chapel in San Leandro, Sun Valley Bible Chapel in Lafayette, Gerber Bible Fellowship in Gerber. There is a directory of pb assemblies in the usa on the internet.
Thanks, Dayle. I’ve added these churches plus a few others. Many of the Brethren assemblies wonderfully exemplify pastoral leadership by a plurality of elders.
Our church has recently become elder-led, and without any one pastor holding the title of “Senior Pastor.” We have adopted bylaws accordingly and are loving the new (non-repressive) structure. The church is located in Hamilton, Montana and is called Bitterroot Harvest Community Church. http://www.bitterrootharvest.com Thanks so much for this blog! It was instrumental in implementing a much-needed change in our church!
Thanks for the link. Looks great! I’ve added you guys to the list. And thank you for the encouragement. I’m so glad the blog was a help to your church. That’s what it’s all about!
We have had an elder lead church in Melbourne FL. For 10 years. It has truly worked so well. There are 3 elders each one accountable to God and to each other.it has been a blessing.
That’s wonderful to hear, Betty. What’s the name of your church? I’d love to add it to my list.
I was introduced to this style of church in Garland Texas called Household of Faith. They have biblical eldership and an open meeting with a slight charismatic vibe.
http://www.hofgarland.org
Thanks for the link, Rob. I’ve added HoF to the list.
In Lansing, MI – Riverview Church (www.rivchurch.com).
Chatham Christian Assembly, listed in North Carolina, no longer exists.
Looks great, Dave. Thanks for the link! And thank you too, Geoff. I’ve edited the list.
Community Bible Church of Williamstown, MA is elder-led.
Please advise name, address,& email of Melbourne Church , as my husband & I would like to visit.
Thanks for your assistance in this matter.
Hi, Margaret. I haven’t personally researched churches in Melbourne, so I don’t know of any that are elder-led. (The churches on this list are just churches I have run across or churches others have recommended as elder-led churches.) I’d suggest exploring some of the websites of churches in Melbourne. If you find any that are elder-led, let me know and I’ll add them to this list!
Clinton St. Bible Chapel in Gresham, Oregon
http://www.clintonstreetbiblechapel.com
Thanks, Dustin. I’ve added the link.
The Resolved Church may be plural elder on paper but is in fact run by its lead pastor, Duane Smets.
I’m sorry to hear that. It’s all too easy to slip back into having one dominant leader, even while having biblical terminology.
https://www.ocfchurch.com/
Joe Hellerman at Oceanside is also a professor of Greek and early church history at Biola University. He also wrote a book called “When the Church was a Family: Recapturing Jesus’ Vision for Authentic Christian Community” in which he discussed the Biblical support for leadership by a plurality of, equal parity, elders.
And don’t forget to add https://orchardefc.org
OCF is listed above (under El Segundo), but I didn’t know about Joe Hellerman’s book. Sounds intriguing. I’ll have to check it out.
We’re committed to the biblical principle of leadership by a team of pastoral elders (and the church where I served previously was led this way), but at this point in our replanting process, our team of pastoral elders is a team of one (me)! I’m not going to add us to this list until we’re actually functioning with at least one other pastor/elder.
Thanks for the comments, and for the book recommendation!
Hellerman recently put on a conference in Littleton, CO in conjunction with BER. They have made all the conference materials available online for free (worksheets, notes, slides, and video). The conference was a condensed study of the book. It was very good. You can access it from the BER website at https://biblicaleldership.com/2017-church-as-family/
Good to know, Todd. Thanks!
Faith Christian Community, Anchorage Alaska
I added you guys to the list. Thanks, Steve!
Please add to your list for Oregon, Pillar Bible Fellowship in the Hood River area. The church is led by a plurality of elders and preach expository sermons.
I added Pillar Bible Fellowship. Thanks, Nathan!
You can add Kihei Baptist Chapel on Maui, Hawaii to this list
Excellent. I’ve added you to the list. Thanks, Jay!
Greenville, SC
LifePoint Church
http://www.lifepointsc.org
I added LifePoint to the list. Thanks, Jon!
Dunning Park Bible Chapel in Redford. MI, an open Plymouth Brethren assembly. Dunningpark.org
I’ve added Dunning Park Bible Chapel to the list. Thanks, Heather!
Hi, the church I go to, Mission Valley Community Chapel, as in Evangelical, Bible believing assembly (Open Plymouth Brethren) in San Diego, California that is Elder lead. From our website-
All leadership is volunteer, enabling the majority of our giving to go to worldwide missions. There are opportunities to serve for those interested in participating, including outreach, hospitality, and music.
Elders
Clint Cable
Scott Raymo
Tom Cantor
Deacons
Ken Willadsen
Sam Burton
https://missionvalleychapel.org/
Hi, Paul. Thanks for the info. I’ve added you folks to the list!
Curt, Central Peninsula Church in Foster City, CA is solidly elder led. I pastored there for 35 years and recently retired. I also wrote a book you can find on Amazon called, “Elders in the Local Church.”
Hi, Mark. Yes, I remember you and the elders at CPC very well. After I finished the pastoral intern program at PBC (in 2000), you guys and I spent some time considering my coming onboard there to pastor the small group ministry. You made another choice, which I think was absolutely the right one for CPC. Kelley and I went to Puerto Rico to lead in replanting an English-speaking church there, and that was the perfect ministry opportunity for us. I enjoyed and appreciate the interaction I had with the CPC elders, and respect the leadership of the church there very much. A criterion for this list, though, are churches that are led by a team of elders with no designated senior or lead pastor. (I note this specifically at the top of this page, and it’s something I address in a number of my posts on eldership.) I don’t think that quite fits the model at CPC, as I understand it. Congratulations on your retirement! And thanks for letting me know about your book. I’ll check it out!
Churches of Christ always have been led by elders, exactly as you describe. I am happy that so many are going to the Bible.
Hey brother! Feel free to add us to your list. Clay Jars Christian Fellowship, located in Rochester, NY.
We are best described as Reformed Baptist.
Hey, Stephen! I’ve added you guys to the list. Love your church name!