Our last Taking Root study explored the issue of tithing. We saw that tithing as a mandatory requirement is tied specifically to the Old Covenant Law. Since we aren’t under the Law of Moses, tithing as an obligatory standard doesn’t apply to us any more than dietary laws or laws on the Sabbath. (For more on tithing, see Are Christians supposed to tithe?) So we discussed the obligations that don’t apply to New Covenant believers in Christ, but we didn’t spend any time looking at how we should be giving. This is our focus this week.
Being a steward
To talk about how we give as Christians, we need to begin with the idea of a “steward.” Even if this isn’t a word you commonly use, we’re all familiar with the concept. Let’s say you own a business, and you hire me to run it for you. This doesn’t mean the business is mine to do with whatever I please. You are entrusting it to me so that I’ll run it the same way you would if you were there. It’s not my business, I’m just overseeing it in your place. I’m a steward of what belongs to you.
This is a key concept in the New Testament. Everything we have has been entrusted to us by God. Our gifts and skills come to us from God, and we’re responsible to use them in a way that’s pleasing to him. Our children don’t really belong to us, God entrusts them to us for a period of time. Even our very lives have been entrusted to us by God for a purpose:
You do not belong to yourself, for God bought you with a high price.
1 Corinthians 6:19-20
To see a good example of financial stewardship we can look at the parable of the three servants in Matthew 25:14-30.
[A man] called together his servants and entrusted his money to them while he was gone.
Later, we’re told:
After a long time their master returned from his trip and called them to give an account of how they had used his money.
Notice the money was still the man’s, and they were responsible for stewarding the money that he had entrusted to them in a way that would be pleasing to their master. To those who did this well, the master said:
Well done, my good and faithful servant. You have been faithful in handling this small amount, so now I will give you many more responsibilities. Let’s celebrate together!
Sometimes, we get the idea that we give 10% of our income to God—and then the rest is ours to do with as we please. But this isn’t a biblical attitude. Everything we have is entrusted to us by God, and we’re responsible to him for how we use all of it. This doesn’t mean we have to donate every cent to some Christian cause. Taking care of our regular needs, investing for the future, and even recreation and entertainment can all be legitimate uses of money according to Scripture. But we should make sure we’re not using the resources God has entrusted to us to do anything that would be displeasing to him. And we need to always remember that everything we have—and we ourselves—belong to him.
In contrast to the Old Covenant law of tithing, the New Testament never gives us a required amount we must contribute. Instead, we’re told:
You must each decide in your heart how much to give. And don’t give reluctantly or in response to pressure. “For God loves a person who gives cheerfully.”
2 Corinthians 9:7
How much should you give? This is between you and God. You shouldn’t let anyone else pressure you to give a certain amount or percentage. And we also shouldn’t be applying pressure to anyone so they’ll give—no matter how subtle we try to be. Those of you who were in the adult study this Sunday, heard Clif Armstrong teach on some of these principles. You’ll also recall the story he told about the church leader who called out during a service: “All of you who are going to give $1,000.00, come up front. Now all of you who are going to give $500.00,” etc. We don’t want anyone to give because we pressure them. This is why we make our offering time as low-key as we can, and why we never have things like giant thermometers at the front to show how much the church has given toward a certain project. Just as with other forms of Christian service, financial giving needs to be prompted by the Holy Spirit—not us.
This also means we need to be careful not to establish an extra-biblical standard of giving for others. Just because giving 10% has worked really well for me, and I happen to think it would be beneficial for all Christians, this doesn’t give me the authority to establish another law or standard for other believers. I may feel that getting up at 3:30 am and praying for 3 hours every day is a wonderful thing to do (this is a hypothetical example; I don’t actually do this), and maybe it is a perfect model for me personally. But this doesn’t mean I should be urging everyone else to do the exact same thing. Some practices God leaves up to our individual consciences—between us and God; how much New Testament believers should give is one of these practices. Don’t try to take the place of the Holy Spirit toward your brothers and sisters.
Notice that God especially loves it when we give cheerfully. This makes sense doesn’t it? Would you enjoy receiving a gift if you had to pressure someone to give to you? What if they did give, but they gave grudgingly, wishing they didn’t have to? That ruins the gift for both of you, doesn’t it? You’d just as soon give that kind of “gift” right back! We need to give to God out of a deep sense of gratitude for what he’s given us, and out of love toward those who need our help. But we can’t try to regulate this process; gifts must come voluntarily from a willing heart.
While we don’t presume to set a percentage or amount for each other, the New Testament does teach us a general principle that we should give in proportion to what God has given us.
Give in proportion to what you have. Whatever you give is acceptable, if you give it eagerly. And give according to what you have, not what you don’t have.
2 Corinthians 8:11-12
Did you see that we’re supposed to give according to what we have, not what we don’t have? This should challenge those who pressure other Christians to give even when they don’t have food on the table or gas in the car. It also shows this isn’t a matter of giving to God in order to get even more back from him. God isn’t some kind of Ponzi scheme. He doesn’t promise to give us a certain return on our investment. He blesses us, and we give in response and gratitude to his blessing. This doesn’t mean God may not at times direct us to give even though we don’t have enough money for our obligations—but this kind of extraordinary calling must come directly from God, not us.
At this point, some of you may be thinking, ‘Well, is 10% a good proportion of my income?’ And the answer is, ‘maybe.’ You need to prayerfully consider your own situation and see what God puts on your heart. 10% can be a great place to start for many of us. Some will be able to go on and give a higher percentage if God leads them to do that. RG LeTourneau is well-known for reaching the point that he could give 90% of his income and live off the other 10%. Some can’t give 10% right away, so they begin with $20 a week, or $10, or $5. I can’t tell you what dollar amount or percentage is right for you. You need to pray and see how God directs you.
Don’t forget that, whatever proportion we decide on, we need to give willingly and cheerfully. I heard of a man who was making $200 a week. He figured 10% was $20 and, though it hurt, he could commit to that. As time went by, he moved up the ranks in his company and received pay raises, and he continued to faithfully contribute 10% of his income. The man became very successful, now making closer to $2,500.00 each week. 10% of $2,500.00 was a lot of money, and he began to feel uneasy about giving so much each week. He went to one of his pastors to talk to him about the problem. He explained his whole history of giving, and the pastor said the solution was simple. Since giving his committed 10% was difficult for him now, but was something he was able to do when he was only making $200 a week, they could just pray together that God would reduce his income down to the point where he could give again!
Sometimes the more God blesses us, the more challenging proportional giving can be. This is because the more money we have, the more opportunities we have for acquiring possessions and experiences. And the more we get, usually the more we want. What seemed like an incredible luxury to me yesterday, is now an essential that I think I can’t live without. As the passage reads that Clif taught from Sunday:
Wherever your treasure is, there the desires of your heart will also be.
Proportional giving provides us with a regular check on the desires of our hearts, to make sure we’re not slipping into greed and hypocrisy (as the Pharisees were in Luke 12).
There is a consistent theme of self-sacrifice running throughout the New Testament. Obviously the perfect example of sacrificing oneself is Jesus. John 3:16 is the classic verse that many of us learned as children:
For God loved the world so much that he gave his one and only Son, so that everyone who believes in him will not perish but have eternal life.
And while this is speaking more of the Father giving the Son, in John 10:18, Jesus said:
No one can take my life from me. I sacrifice it voluntarily. For I have the authority to lay it down when I want to and also to take it up again.
But while many know John 3:16 by heart, not as many are immediately familiar with
1 John 3:16:
We know what real love is because Jesus laid down his life for us. So we also ought to lay down our lives for our brothers and sisters.
Scripture calls us to show our love for God and each other by giving our time and energy, and by giving financially. The healthy, biblical Christian life includes both kinds of giving. This doesn’t mean we should make ourselves guilty if we’re not giving away everything we have (either time or money). Notice again the instructions in 2 Corinthians 8:12-14:
And give according to what you have, not what you don’t have. Of course, I don’t mean your giving should make life easy for others and hard for yourselves. I only mean that there should be some equality. Right now you have plenty and can help those who are in need. Later, they will have plenty and can share with you when you need it. In this way, things will be equal.
These are a few biblical principles teaching us how believers should give. But the underlying principle we see everywhere in the New Testament is that we are to be like Christ. Sometimes our giving will cost us something. It will be a sacrifice. It was for Jesus, wasn’t it? Love, generosity and self-sacrifice should characterize our lives. As we freely receive all good things from God, so we should freely give in heartfelt, grateful response.
14 thoughts on “New Testament principles of giving”
Curt, I love your posts and especially the two on tithing. I have been in churches that teach tithing, especially appealing to Malachi 3. The other thing that is often taught is that we should give 10% (at least) to the local congregation where we worship, appealing to “the storehouse” as the Old Testament corollary to the church (i.e. local congregation). This may be a good idea for a lot of reasons, but is there any biblical basis for teaching this. What does the Bible say about where we give our offering? Thanks a bunch.
Thanks, Larry. Sorry for the late response. It’s been a busy weekend.
There aren’t any passages that teach us to give at least 10% to the local church, and I can’t think of any that even specify the local church as a priority in our giving. As you point out, this doesn’t mean it’s not a good thing to do, just that it’s not explicitly taught in Scripture. We are taught that those who labor in ministry should be supported financially in passages such as 1 Timothy 5:17, Galatians 6:6, and 1 Corinthians 9. Galatians 6:10 tells us to do good to everyone, but especially those in the family of faith. We could expand this to mean we should first give to those to whom we’re most responsible (e.g. first our family, then our local church, then our community, etc.), but this isn’t explicitly stated. I would say this is a wisdom issue rather than one of obedience to a clear, specific command.
Great…I really enjoyed it and have leant a lot from it. Upon deciding to comit to 10% of my pay as tithe for Gods course I decided to rope in my wife as part of the fulfillment of the commandment in Malachi. I told her to round the 10% to the next dollar but that resulted in an argument. Immediately I saw the giving was not from her heart and so allowed her to stick to the decimal numbers. Even though I reminded her that we were supposed to give cheerfully I wasn’t going to let her fall short of her 10% tithe which I taught was an obligation on christians – failure on our part which could result in some curses. I think this teaching has been very helpful to me. Three things I picked from this are stewardshiip, cheerful giving and proportionate giving.
James, I’m so glad if this has been helpful to you. In regards to your wife, I’d just remind you of the words Jesus quoted in Matthew 12:7: “I desire mercy, not sacrifice.”
God bless you, brother,
Great Message! I enjoyed Part 1 of your messages on tithing, and Part 2 has encouraged me to continue to give!
Good to hear!
What about the parable of the withered fig tree and Jesus flipping tables in the temple square? We shouldn’t even be going to churches let alone giving them our money. Pray and study in the new temple (yourself) and give to people who need it.
Okay, Jordan, I’ll bite. What about the parable of the withered fig tree and Jesus flipping tables in the temple square? How do you get from these passages to: “We shouldn’t even be going to churches let alone giving them our money”? You’ll have to explain your interpretation a bit more. And by going to churches, are you referring to church buildings or groups of believers? BTW, the new temple is not you by yourself, it’s all the New Covenant people of God, together (e.g. 1 Corinthians 3:16; 1 Peter 2:5).
I am referring to the physical buildings. Churches these days would ashame jesus. The parable of the fig tree was to show that the temple is dead and produces no fruit. The new church is the Christian people. Lazarus and the rich man says a bit about this. The rich churches who think they are holy will be denied mercy in hell. The true church who gives his money where it is needed… And all excess money, that is, as well, will be welcomed into the bossom of Abraham.
Does your pastor really need that Cadillac? Or could that Kenyan use a meal instead?
Well, Jordan, you don’t really establish your view, but you do state it confidently. Thanks for sharing.
How is my view not established? My view is biblically supported.
First, Jordan, anyone can say their view is biblically supported. It’s one thing to refer to a clear, commonly-accepted command such as “love one another,” it’s quite another to propose distinctive interpretations of a parable and a narrative passage. If we were going to discuss this it wouldn’t be enough to just state (and restate) your interpretation, you would need to ‘show your work’ so to speak and explain why your interpretation makes best sense of the passage.
But more germane to this discussion, the original post did not focus at all on temples (OT or NT) or churches. It was on NT principles of giving. I didn’t even address the issue of to whom we should give or for what causes. Did you read the original post? I should have let you know this right away (my bad), but please don’t comment again unless you’re responding directly to something in the original article. Thanks.
The fig tree parable is clear as well. He curses the fig tree, destroys the temple and then explains that the fig tree is dead from the roots. How would you interpret that? The Lazarus and the rich man story clearly shows that ignoring the poor while feeding yourself is enough to be sent to hell. How would you interpret that differently?
This is directly related to your article about giving. But you can ignore me if it makes you uncomfortable.
1. Jesus didn’t destroy the Temple at that time, he cleansed it. It wasn’t the Temple itself that he was confronting, it was the people of Israel and their corruption of the Covenant (including their corrupted use of the Temple). It was because the Temple was to be kept holy that he drove out the moneychangers.
2. Your interpretation of the parable of Lazarus and the rich man is overly simplistic, and doesn’t address the historical context and background of the story. Have you checked your interpretation against those of biblical scholars and commentators? Notice that Jesus never specifies why the rich man was in torment. Using your reasoning, we could also assume that all poor people go to heaven.
3. Your first comment (which didn’t mention Lazarus and the rich man) had absolutely nothing to do with the original post. This parable does relate indirectly to the very broad subject of giving, but I don’t see where you’ve used it in a way that is specifically and directly related to the original article. If you have things to say about the subject that go beyond my article, by all means write your own article and express your views. But if you’re going to comment here, please comment on the original post not on your distinctive views on giving.
4. Snide comments such as: But you can ignore me if it makes you uncomfortable are unacceptable on this blog. This implies that if someone doesn’t want to discuss what you want to discuss, then they must be bothered by the truth you’re expressing. That would be quite an arrogant implication, and I hope it wasn’t your intention. If you want to interact here, keep it respectful and in direct response to the original post. (This means no more discussion in this comment thread about the fig tree, the Temple, Lazarus and the rich man, or going to churches. Not because they make me “uncomfortable,” but because they don’t directly relate to the original post.)
Comments are closed.